Do Odds That Shorten Before Kickoff Win More Often? What 100,000 Matches Show

Line movement sits at the heart of “smart money” betting: odds that shorten are supposed to show where professional money is going. But does a moving line actually tell you anything, and can you make money from it? We checked 100,585 football matches from 22 European leagues, comparing each price a few days before kickoff with the final price at kickoff.

The short answer: yes, line moves carry real information. But the value is in the price before the move, not in following it afterwards.

Key findings

  • Teams whose odds shortened by more than 10% before kickoff won 31.3% of the time. The early odds had implied only 26.7%, the closing odds 31.3%.
  • Bet at the early price, those selections returned +12.7% per bet. Bet at the closing price, the same selections returned −4.5%.
  • Selections whose odds drifted by more than 10% lost 20.9% per bet at the early price.
  • Shortening selections beat drifting ones in 14 of 14 seasons.
  • The catch: you only know which way a line moved after it has moved. Once it has, the edge is gone.

The data and the method

We used the free historical odds from football-data.co.uk for 22 European leagues from 2012/13 to 2025/26: every match where both prices from Pinnacle were available. Pinnacle is a bookmaker known for low margins and high limits, so its prices are widely used as a reference for the “true” market.

  • Early odds: recorded by football-data.co.uk on Friday afternoon for weekend matches and on Tuesday afternoon for midweek matches, usually one to three days before kickoff.
  • Closing odds: the last price before kickoff.
  • Movement: the change from early to closing odds for every home, draw and away price, 301,755 prices in total. 73% moved by more than 2%, 44% by more than 5%.
  • Implied probability: 1 ÷ odds, with Pinnacle’s margin removed (3.3% on early odds, 3.0% on closing odds).

Result 1: the closing price knows almost exactly how often teams win

Actual win rate minus the probability implied by the odds
vs. early oddsvs. closing odds
−6 pp −4 pp −2 pp 0 +2 pp +4 pp +6 pp Shortened >10%: won 31.3% of 21,071 bets · early odds implied 26.7%, closing odds 31.3% Shortened >10% Shortened 5–10%: won 35.4% of 37,044 bets · early odds implied 33.2%, closing odds 35.8% Shortened 5–10% Shortened 2–5%: won 36.5% of 45,274 bets · early odds implied 35.3%, closing odds 36.6% Shortened 2–5% Stable ±2%: won 35.9% of 81,650 bets · early odds implied 35.3%, closing odds 35.4% Stable ±2% Drifted 2–5%: won 33.5% of 43,297 bets · early odds implied 34.5%, closing odds 33.4% Drifted 2–5% Drifted 5–10%: won 31.3% of 38,240 bets · early odds implied 33.4%, closing odds 31.3% Drifted 5–10% Drifted >10%: won 24.3% of 35,179 bets · early odds implied 29.0%, closing odds 25.0% Drifted >10% +4.5 pp −4.6 pp
In percentage points (pp). Positive = the selection won more often than the odds implied. Hover over a bar for details. Source: football-data.co.uk, 22 European leagues, 2012/13–2025/26, Pinnacle odds. Analysis: GamblingSociety.

Look at the orange bars first: for every group, the closing odds were almost perfectly right, off by less than one percentage point. The blue bars tell the story of the move. Selections that shortened by more than 10% won 4.5 percentage points more often than their early odds implied. Selections that drifted by more than 10% won 4.6 points less often. In other words: the market corrected the early price in the right direction, and by kickoff it had caught up.

Result 2: the money is in the early price

Average return per bet: early odds vs. closing odds
Bet at early oddsBet at closing odds
−25% −20% −15% −10% −5% 0 +5% +10% +15% Shortened >10%: +12.7% per bet at early odds, −4.5% at closing odds Shortened >10% Shortened 5–10%: +2.6% per bet at early odds, −4.7% at closing odds Shortened 5–10% Shortened 2–5%: −0.8% per bet at early odds, −4.1% at closing odds Shortened 2–5% Stable ±2%: −1.9% per bet at early odds, −1.9% at closing odds Stable ±2% Drifted 2–5%: −7.0% per bet at early odds, −3.9% at closing odds Drifted 2–5% Drifted 5–10%: −10.3% per bet at early odds, −4.0% at closing odds Drifted 5–10% Drifted >10%: −20.9% per bet at early odds, −7.4% at closing odds Drifted >10% +12.7% −20.9%
Flat 1-unit bet on every selection in each group. Hover over a bar for details. Source: football-data.co.uk, 22 European leagues, 2012/13–2025/26, Pinnacle odds. Analysis: GamblingSociety.
Odds move (early → closing)BetsWonImplied: earlyImplied: closingReturn at early oddsReturn at closing odds
Shortened by more than 10%21,07131.3%26.7%31.3%+12.7%−4.5%
Shortened 5–10%37,04435.4%33.2%35.8%+2.6%−4.7%
Shortened 2–5%45,27436.5%35.3%36.6%−0.8%−4.1%
Stable (±2%)81,65035.9%35.3%35.4%−1.9%−1.9%
Drifted 2–5%43,29733.5%34.5%33.4%−7.0%−3.9%
Drifted 5–10%38,24031.3%33.4%31.3%−10.3%−4.0%
Drifted by more than 10%35,17924.3%29.0%25.0%−20.9%−7.4%
Pinnacle early and closing odds, 2012/13–2025/26. “Implied” = probability from the odds with the bookmaker margin removed.

At the closing price, every group lost money, roughly 2% to 7% per bet, roughly the bookmaker margin plus the known extra cost of long odds (see our analysis Are Favourites Overpriced?). At the early price, the picture splits: bets that the market later moved towards made money, bets it moved away from lost heavily.

Is it consistent?

Yes. In every one of the 14 seasons, selections that shortened by more than 5% returned more at the early price than selections that drifted by more than 5%. One honest caveat: in 2025/26, the shortening group returned −5.6% at the early price, the only negative season in the dataset. One season can be noise, but it is worth watching whether the market is getting faster.


What this means for your betting

  • Line moves are information, not noise. Between the early price and kickoff, the market gets measurably better at pricing a match.
  • Following a move after it happened does not pay. The shortening group returned −4.5% at the closing price. By the time a move is obvious, the value has been priced in.
  • Being early is the only thing that pays, and it is exactly what closing line value (CLV) measures. If the odds you took are regularly higher than the closing odds, you are on the right side of the moves. It is the most reliable sign of real skill that a bettor can track.
  • Tools that show line movement help you understand the market: for example the ZCode Line Reversal Tool. But speed matters: a move you see on a chart has usually already happened. Use such tools to learn how markets react, not as a signal to chase finished moves.
  • Track your own CLV. Note the odds you took and the closing odds for every bet: our free Bet Tracker or a simple spreadsheet is enough. See How to Track Your Sports Bets.

What this analysis does not show

  • The groups are defined after the fact. Nobody knows on Friday afternoon which lines will move, so the +12.7% is not a strategy you could have followed. It shows what knowing the direction is worth.
  • The early odds are one snapshot from one bookmaker at one point in time. Other bookmakers, other times and your own stake limits may give different results.
  • It covers 1X2 markets in European football only, not handicaps, totals, other sports or live betting.
  • Past results do not guarantee future results: see the 2025/26 exception above.

Frequently asked questions

Do odds that shorten before kickoff win more often?

Yes. More often than their early odds implied. Selections that shortened by more than 10% won 31.3% of the time, while their early odds implied 26.7%. Their closing odds (31.3%) were almost exactly right.

Is it profitable to follow line movement?

Not after the move has happened. In our data, betting shortening selections at the closing price returned −4.5% per bet. The value only existed at the earlier, higher price.

What is closing line value?

Closing line value (CLV) compares the odds you took with the final odds at kickoff. Because closing odds are the most accurate prices, consistently beating them is the best available sign that your bets have a positive expected value.

Where does the data come from?

From football-data.co.uk, which publishes free historical results and bookmaker odds. We used Pinnacle’s early and closing odds for 100,585 matches from 22 European leagues. All numbers were calculated by us from that data.


Related guides

About the author: GamblingSociety is an independent site run by Andreas, who has operated casino and betting guides since the mid-2000s. No bookmaker or casino owns or pays for our content. More about us.