Every summer the same question comes up: are promoted teams worth backing, or does the step up catch them out? Newly promoted sides often start with energy and a home crowd that has waited years for top-flight football. We checked every match of 557 promoted teams in their first season after promotion, across 11 European leagues since 2006/07, and compared their results with what the bookmakers expected.
The short answer: promoted teams are slightly overrated by the betting market. Backing them lost 10.5% per bet at average odds, against 7.1% for all other teams. The gap is too small to bet against them blindly. It is consistent, though, and it shows up at a clear point in the season.
Key findings
- Newly promoted sides won 30.0% of their matches. Their odds implied 30.4%. That small gap was enough to turn an average loss of 7.1% into 10.5% per bet.
- The gap holds at Pinnacle’s closing odds, the sharpest prices in the market: −7.0% for promoted sides, −2.9% for everyone else.
- It comes mostly from away games and from matches where the promoted side was the underdog.
- The first five games are priced fairly. The overrating builds from game six and is largest between games 20 and 29 (−14.6% per bet).
- 27% of promoted teams went straight back down. In the Premier League it was 47%, in League Two none at all.
Contents
The data and the method
We used the free historical results and odds from football-data.co.uk. A team counts as promoted if it played in the division directly below in the previous season. That covers automatic promotion and play-off winners. We can only see this where the lower division is in the data, so the analysis uses 11 leagues:
- England: Premier League, Championship, League One and League Two
- Germany: Bundesliga; Italy: Serie A; Spain: La Liga; France: Ligue 1
- Scotland: Premiership, Championship and League One
The period runs from 2006/07 to 2025/26: 80,547 matches, 22,104 of them with a promoted team. For every team in every match we calculated the return of a flat one-unit bet at three prices: the market average, the best price on offer, and (from 2012/13) Pinnacle’s closing odds. “Implied” means the win probability from the average odds once the bookmaker margin is removed.
Promoted teams lose bettors more money
| Bet on… | Bets | Won | Implied by odds | Return, average odds | Return, best price | Return, Pinnacle close | Points per game: real / expected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Promoted teams | 22,104 | 30.0% | 30.4% | −10.5% | −3.0% | −7.0% | 1.16 / 1.18 |
| All other teams | 119,024 | 37.1% | 36.8% | −7.1% | −0.8% | −2.9% | 1.37 / 1.37 |
| Opponents of promoted teams | 19,966 | 45.0% | 43.9% | −5.4% | −0.2% | −1.9% | 1.61 / 1.58 |
The bookmakers were not far off. Promoted sides won 30.0% of their games while the odds expected 30.4%, and they collected 1.16 points per game instead of the expected 1.18. But a betting market works on small margins. Those 0.4 percentage points were enough to make them the worst group in the table: 10.5% lost per bet at average odds, compared with 7.1% for all other teams.
Is that just chance? With 22,104 bets, the difference is about three standard errors, so pure luck is unlikely. They did worse than the rest in 14 of 20 seasons, and backing them was not profitable in a single season. At Pinnacle’s closing odds the gap gets bigger, not smaller (−7.0% against −2.9%), which suggests that even the sharpest prices rate newcomers a little too high.
Where the gap comes from
| Situation | Promoted teams: won / implied | Promoted teams: return | All other teams: return |
|---|---|---|---|
| At home | 36.6% / 36.7% | −8.2% | −6.0% |
| Away | 23.4% / 24.2% | −12.8% | −8.2% |
| As favourite | 46.1% / 44.8% | −4.2% | −4.6% |
| As underdog | 21.6% / 22.9% | −13.7% | −9.7% |
At home, promoted sides won about as often as the odds said (36.6% against 36.7% implied), and the return was closer to the rest (−8.2% against −6.0% for other home teams). Away from home they won 23.4% of their games while the odds expected 24.2%, and backing them lost 12.8% per bet.
The same pattern shows by role. When a promoted team was the favourite, it did as well as any other favourite. As an underdog, which is the usual role for a newly promoted side, it lost 13.7% per bet against 9.7% for other underdogs. The market seems to give promoted teams a little too much credit when they travel to established opponents.
When in the season promoted teams are overrated
This is the most interesting part. In their first five games, the newcomers were priced fairly: −6.5% per bet, slightly better than other teams in the same weeks. Their points matched expectations (1.17 per game against 1.16 expected).
From game six onwards the picture changes. Between games 11 and 19 backing them lost 13.4% per bet, between games 20 and 29 14.6%. Their points dropped to 1.13 per game while the odds still expected 1.17. In the final stretch of the season (game 30 onwards) the gap closes again (−6.1%).
One possible reading: the market starts with a sensible estimate, then follows the early results and the enthusiasm around a promoted club for too long. When reality catches up in winter, the odds adjust slowly. Each stage holds between 2,784 and 5,969 bets, so the exact numbers per stage are rough, but the shape is clear.
Promoted teams by league
The effect is strongest in the big leagues. In the Premier League, backing promoted teams lost 14.6% per bet against 5.6% for the rest, and almost half of them (47%) went straight back down. Serie A looks similar. In the Bundesliga, La Liga and the Championship promoted sides were priced about as accurately as everyone else.

| League ↕ | Promoted teams ↕ | Relegated straight back ↕ | Promoted: return ↕ | Promoted: best price ↕ | Other teams: return ↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Serie A | 60 | 39% | −15.7% | −7.4% | −10.4% |
| Scottish Premiership | 25 | 13% | −15.6% | −8.9% | −6.9% |
| Premier League | 60 | 47% | −14.6% | −7.4% | −5.6% |
| Scottish Championship | 35 | 29% | −13.2% | −4.9% | −10.2% |
| Ligue 1 | 55 | 37% | −12.0% | −3.9% | −7.5% |
| Scottish League One | 37 | 17% | −9.5% | −1.4% | −7.2% |
| League Two (ENG 4) | 40 | 0% | −8.8% | −2.9% | −6.4% |
| League One (ENG 3) | 79 | 16% | −8.4% | −1.8% | −7.3% |
| La Liga | 60 | 30% | −7.6% | +1.5% | −7.4% |
| Championship (ENG 2) | 60 | 23% | −7.4% | −0.9% | −6.3% |
| Bundesliga | 46 | 34% | −6.9% | +1.1% | −5.8% |
For the five big leagues together (281 promoted teams), backing promoted sides lost 11.6% per bet, other teams 7.4%. League Two stands out in a different way: of 38 clubs promoted from the National League, not one was relegated straight back. The step from non-league to League Two seems smaller than its reputation.
And the relegated teams?
The mirror case is just as interesting. Teams that came down from the league above (544 relegated teams in their first season in the lower division) won 41.8% of their games against 40.9% implied. Backing them lost 6.3% per bet, less than the 8.6% for other teams in those leagues.
So the market seems slightly too optimistic about the team that just went up and slightly too cautious about the team that just came down. Both effects are small, and neither turns into a profit at average odds.
Is betting against promoted teams a strategy?
If promoted teams are overrated, their opponents should be underrated. They were, a little: backing every opponent of a promoted team lost 5.4% per bet at average odds, 0.2% at the best price and 1.9% at Pinnacle’s closing odds. That is better than betting on random teams, but it is still a loss.
Our view: treat promotion as one input when you judge a match. On its own it is no betting system. If you already have a reason to like the opponent, the data says the price is probably a bit better than usual.
What this means for your bets
- Be careful with promoted teams away from home. That is where the odds were furthest off.
- Early-season hype is priced in. The first weeks were fair, and the overrating comes later, when results have cooled and the odds have not.
- Look at the league. The effect was strong in the Premier League, Serie A and Ligue 1 and small in the Bundesliga, La Liga and the Championship.
- Get the best price. At average odds no group in this analysis came close to a profit. The difference between average and best price was larger than any effect we found.
- Measure yourself. Compare your odds with the closing line (closing line value) and track your bets, for example with our free Bet Tracker.
What this analysis does not show
- It covers the first season after promotion in 11 leagues. Leagues whose lower division is not in the data (for example the 2. Bundesliga, Serie B or the Süper Lig) are not included.
- It does not look at budgets, transfers or managers. A well-funded promoted club and a shoestring one count the same.
- Per-league numbers rest on 25 to 79 promoted teams each. Differences between single leagues are partly random.
- The current season 2026/27 is not part of the analysis. Until 20 September, backing promoted teams returned −1.0% per bet on 168 bets, which fits the fair early-season pricing above.
FAQ: promoted teams in betting
Are promoted teams overrated by bookmakers?
Slightly. In 11 European leagues since 2006/07, promoted sides won 30.0% of their matches while the odds implied 30.4%. Backing them lost 10.5% per bet at average odds, against 7.1% for all other teams.
How many promoted teams go straight back down?
Across the 11 leagues, 27% of 529 promoted teams were relegated after one season. In the Premier League it was 47%, in Serie A 39%, in the Bundesliga 34% and in League Two none.
Should you bet against promoted teams?
Not blindly. Backing every opponent of a promoted team lost 5.4% per bet at average odds and 0.2% at the best price. It is a small advantage over random bets, not a profitable system.
Are promoted teams good bets early in the season?
They were priced fairly. In their first five games, backing them returned −6.5% per bet at average odds, slightly better than other teams. The overrating starts after that.
Where does the data come from?
From football-data.co.uk, which publishes free historical results and bookmaker odds. We used 80,547 matches from 11 European leagues, 2006/07 to 2025/26. All numbers were calculated by us from that data.
Related guides
- Over 2.5 Goals by League: goals and over/under odds in 22 leagues.
- Are Favourites Overpriced?: the favourite-longshot bias in 161,885 matches.
- Is Home Advantage Disappearing?: home advantage before, during and after COVID.
- Does team form beat the market?: our test of hot and cold streaks.
- Lucky Winners and Unlucky Losers: shots on target against the score in 111,494 matches.
