Ask ten bettors where the value is and most will point at the underdog. The favourite is “priced in”, the public piles onto big teams, so the bookmaker surely shortens their odds too far, right? It is one of the most repeated ideas in sports betting. So we checked it against the data: 161,885 football matches from 22 European leagues, covering 21 complete seasons.
The short answer: no. Favourites are not overpriced. Longshots are. And not by a little.
Key findings
- Betting on every favourite (odds under 2.0) at average bookmaker odds lost 3.8% per bet. Betting on every longshot (odds over 5.0) lost 19.6%.
- The bigger the outsider, the worse the deal: bets at odds over 10 lost 36.9% of the stake on average.
- Favourites beat longshots in 21 of 21 seasons, and clearly in 21 of 22 leagues. The one exception: the German Bundesliga.
- None of this is a winning strategy. Favourites still lost money. They were just far less expensive.
The data and the method
We used the free historical results and odds from football-data.co.uk: the top divisions and several lower leagues of England, Scotland, Germany, Italy, Spain, France, the Netherlands, Belgium, Portugal, Turkey and Greece, from 2005/06 to 2025/26. The current season was left out because it is incomplete.
For every match we took the average bookmaker odds for home win, draw and away win (1X2) and imagined a flat 1-unit bet on each outcome. That gives about 486,000 bets. For each odds range we then asked one question: what did you get back per unit staked? A return of −5% means that for every €100 you bet, you got €95 back on average.
Result: the longer the odds, the bigger the bookmaker’s cut
At short odds you lose very little: a favourite priced between 1.01 and 1.25 returned −0.6%, almost break-even. From there the losses grow steadily. At 2.01–2.50 you lose 5.6%, at 4.01–6.00 already 12.8%, and beyond odds of 10 more than a third of every stake disappears.
The reason becomes clear when you compare the odds with what actually happened. Odds over 10 imply a win probability of about 7.5%. Those teams actually won only 4.9% of the time. At the other end, odds of 1.01–1.25 implied an 84.9% chance, and those favourites won 84.4%, very close to fair.
| Odds range | Bets | Won | Implied by odds | Return per bet |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.01–1.25 | 5,609 | 84.4% | 84.9% | −0.6% |
| 1.26–1.50 | 15,362 | 70.7% | 72.0% | −2.0% |
| 1.51–1.75 | 25,901 | 58.6% | 61.1% | −4.1% |
| 1.76–2.00 | 31,953 | 50.5% | 53.2% | −5.2% |
| 2.01–2.50 | 70,325 | 42.1% | 44.6% | −5.6% |
| 2.51–3.00 | 65,034 | 33.2% | 36.2% | −8.2% |
| 3.01–4.00 | 185,854 | 27.1% | 29.6% | −8.6% |
| 4.01–6.00 | 58,404 | 18.7% | 21.4% | −12.8% |
| 6.01–10.0 | 20,257 | 11.1% | 13.8% | −19.8% |
| over 10 | 6,958 | 4.9% | 7.5% | −36.9% |
This pattern has a name: the favourite-longshot bias. It was first described for horse racing in 1949 (Griffith, American Journal of Psychology) and has since been found in many betting markets, including UK football (Cain, Law & Peel, Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 2000). Our data shows it is still alive in European football today.
Is it just a few lucky seasons?
No. We split the data by season and compared all favourites (odds under 2.0) with all longshots (odds over 5.0). Favourites lost less in every single one of the 21 seasons.
The longshot line jumps around more because there are fewer longshot bets per season and each win pays a lot: one or two surprise results move the number. But it never comes close to the favourite line.
League by league: strong in Greece and Portugal, absent in the Bundesliga
The effect is not equally strong everywhere. It was largest in the Greek Super League (favourites −2.1%, longshots −35.1%), the Portuguese Primeira Liga (−0.8% vs −34.1%) and Italy’s Serie A (−0.3% vs −23.8%). In the Premier League, favourites returned −1.7% and longshots −13.1%.
The one clear exception is the German Bundesliga: favourites −5.7%, longshots −5.9%, no measurable difference. We don’t have a proven explanation for that, and we won’t invent one. Keep in mind that single leagues have far fewer bets than the whole dataset, so longshot figures per league can easily be off by 4–9 percentage points either way.
What about sharper bookmakers?
Average odds include soft bookmakers with high margins. So we repeated the test with Pinnacle’s closing odds (available from 2012/13), a bookmaker known for low margins and for taking big bets. The margin is smaller across the board, but the shape is the same:
| Odds range | Average odds | Pinnacle closing odds |
|---|---|---|
| 1.01–1.25 | −0.6% | +0.3% |
| 1.26–1.50 | −2.0% | 0.0% |
| 1.76–2.00 | −5.2% | −2.8% |
| 2.51–3.00 | −8.2% | −3.0% |
| 4.01–6.00 | −12.8% | −5.9% |
| 6.01–10.0 | −19.8% | −8.4% |
| over 10 | −36.9% | −25.5% |
What this means for your betting
- Longshots are the most expensive product in the shop. A bet at odds of 12 feels cheap because the stake is small and the dream is big, but you pay by far the highest margin. Accumulators make this worse: every longshot leg adds its own large margin.
- “Just back favourites” is not a strategy. Favourites still lost 3.8% per bet at average odds. Less bad is not the same as good.
- The price matters more than the pick. The difference between average odds and Pinnacle’s odds is bigger than the difference between most betting “systems”. Compare prices before every bet: our Odds Converter shows you the implied probability of any price.
- Only bet when you think the odds are wrong. That is what expected value means, and closing line value is the best way to check afterwards whether you really had an edge.
- Size your stakes. If you do find value, the Kelly Criterion Calculator shows how much to stake, and why longshots need much smaller stakes.
What this analysis does not show
- It covers only 1X2 (home/draw/away) markets in European football, not handicaps, totals, other sports or live betting.
- Average odds are an average across bookmakers. On any given match you might get better or worse prices.
- At the best available price across all bookmakers, short favourites even show a small positive return (around +2%). We don’t treat that as a strategy: the best price is picked after the fact from dozens of bookmakers, may only have been available briefly, and bookmakers limit accounts that consistently take it.
- Past results do not guarantee future results. Markets change: bookmaker margins, for example, fell from about 11% in 2005/06 to around 6–8% in recent seasons.
Frequently asked questions
Are favourites good value in football betting?
Not in the sense of being profitable: at average odds, favourites lost 3.8% per bet over 21 seasons. But they are much better value than longshots, which lost 19.6%.
What is the favourite-longshot bias?
It is the tendency for longshots to be priced too short relative to their real chance of winning, while favourites are priced close to fair. As a result, the bookmaker’s effective margin is much larger on outsiders than on favourites.
Why do bookmakers take a bigger margin on underdogs?
Two common explanations: many bettors overpay for the chance of a big payout (the same appeal as a lottery ticket), and bookmakers protect themselves against rare but expensive upsets. Our data shows the effect; it does not prove which explanation is right.
Where does the data come from?
From football-data.co.uk, which publishes free historical results and bookmaker odds for more than 20 European leagues. All numbers in this article were calculated by us from that data.
Related guides
- Value Betting in Practice: how to spot prices that are actually wrong.
- How Sportsbooks Set Odds: where the bookmaker margin comes from.
- Why Most Bettors Lose: the maths of the vig, explained.
- Bankroll Management for Sports Betting: protect your bankroll while you learn.
- Do Odds That Shorten Before Kickoff Win More Often?: our second data analysis, on what line moves are really worth.
- Is Home Advantage Disappearing?: our third data analysis, on home advantage before, during and after COVID.
- Over 2.5 Goals by League: the same favourite-longshot bias, found again in the over/under 2.5 goals market.
- How Safe Is a Half-Time Lead?: the same favourite-longshot bias in the price of the draw.
